Film Reviews, Criticism, Discussion
From: fear7trembling - I hope you're watching when it #1
Date: 01/27/26 @ 5:34 PM
If we don't follow you on Letterboxd or whatever, that's fine, we have a thread for that.

But if you're doing a deep dive, or reminiscing, or have genre thoughts, let's do it.

Do I like you? I don't know, probably not. But if you watched Audition (1999) or Teorema (1968) or The Virgin Spring (1960) or even Evil Dead Trap (1980) (don't do that, actually), I want to hear it.

It's a lot of bad criticism that wobbles between seriousness and farce, and it's annoying, but it's a few good minds on here and I always want to hear it, because I am a cultural addict.

Anyway it feels like I owe it to start with something, so Weapons (2025) was upsetting and also one of the funniest films I've ever seen.

Yes, the vampire witch is a problem, but also no one in this town can keep a handle on themselves, which is why you are targeting a meek schoolteacher, who also kind of sucks, but more eminently is a reminder of actual witch trials, where you just ruin a woman's life because they're weird and don't need you.

I think there's an important distinction between Horror For Comedy's Sake and horror that makes you laugh. One requires that you be outside of it, and the other wants you to breathe and embrace absurdity for what it is.

Others have complained about the pacing and structure, but I think that's a critical part of it, because Cregger said that he wrote about fifty pages before he had any idea where it was going. Which, given the end product, with the overlapping and intertwined character-based stories, is astounding. It's like you're learning along with the creation of it. Not necessarily collaboration, but revelation.

Anyway, yeah. Love it. There's a undercurrent of frustration and violence running throughout and if I were a life-draining entity I'd be like, okay.

I don't believe in ten-point scales but 3.5/4.
From: Mantis55 #2
Date: 01/27/26 @ 5:45 PM
People who disliked the storytelling structure of Weapons will have any future opinions ignored.

It's incredible.
From: bepto #3
Date: 01/27/26 @ 6:00 PM
Oh cool a Marvel movies thread
From: fear7trembling - I hope you're watching when it #4
Date: 01/27/26 @ 6:03 PM
I'm actually going to preemptively b
From: GoonGoonington - Straight Panic, Gay Excellence #5
Date: 01/27/26 @ 7:15 PM
I hate horror movies and yet I loved Weapons.
From: fear7trembling - I hope you're watching when it #6
Date: 01/27/26 @ 7:45 PM
People who disliked the storytelling structure of Weapons will have any future opinions ignored.
I mean, it was "experimental", if not new.
But Cregger did say that the episodic style came from him writing about people that he has lost in his life,
So it's not just fragmented, but confessional.
I don't know, it's a lot.
From: butterknife - calcium depraved #7
Date: 01/27/26 @ 9:52 PM
welcome to the dollhouse
an incredibly nostalgic film
From: fear7trembling - I hope you're watching when it #8
Date: 01/28/26 @ 12:03 AM
There was an extended period where I kept trying to find Dolls (1987) and I kept thinking it was Valley of the Dolls (1967) or Welcome to the Dollhouse (1995) and I Just ended up confused.
Dolls is awful, by the way, but there are a couple iconic scenes.
From: haze - up the back stairs #9
Date: 01/28/26 @ 12:36 AM
I think Weapons was overall my favorite movie last year.
From: Ransome #10
Date: 01/28/26 @ 12:42 AM
I think barbarian is better
From: haze - up the back stairs #11
Date: 01/28/26 @ 1:05 AM
MODS!?
From: fear7trembling - I hope you're watching when it #12
Date: 01/28/26 @ 1:18 AM
Barbarian came out in 2021 you dork.
From: haze - up the back stairs #13
Date: 01/28/26 @ 1:23 AM
I was going to mention Flow, but didn't realize it was 2024.
From: Rob #14
Date: 01/28/26 @ 1:53 AM
Man weapons was corny as hell at the end sorry
From: chobbler - - - - - - billy bumpkin here - #15
Date: 01/28/26 @ 1:54 AM
mods, delete this man
From: Rob #16
Date: 01/28/26 @ 1:55 AM
Sinners without the
Spoiler vampire
stuff would have been a much better movie
From: fear7trembling - I hope you're watching when it #17
Date: 01/28/26 @ 1:56 AM
mods, delete this man
You didn't have to Thom Yorke on me.
From: Rob #18
Date: 01/28/26 @ 2:00 AM
And also spare me the whole Irish were the real slaves shit shut the fuck up
From: fear7trembling - I hope you're watching when it #19
Date: 01/28/26 @ 2:01 AM
Also I have to disagree, Weapons was about inexplicable and ridiculous terror and violence and the only people that everyone hated figuring out how to turn it the actual villain to culminate in her crashing through their windows and screaming chased by children who tore her to pieces ruled.

Cregger tried to make sense of the many tragedies in his life and managed to turn it into a story.
From: fear7trembling - I hope you're watching when it #20
Date: 01/28/26 @ 2:03 AM
And also spare me the whole Irish were the real slaves shit shut the fuck up
Is that what you think Sinners was doing?
From: Rob #21
Date: 01/28/26 @ 2:08 AM
No just the that one guy I feel like I can talk about parts of it without being scolded here
From: Rob #22
Date: 01/28/26 @ 2:11 AM
Maybe I just didn’t like remick
From: fear7trembling - I hope you're watching when it #23
Date: 01/28/26 @ 2:11 AM
Okay because I feel like Coogler made it pretty clear about vampirism being cultural power for the dispossessed and superceding and absorbing people. If you let it in, it will go all the way up.
From: Rob #24
Date: 01/28/26 @ 2:12 AM
The fight scene still sucked tho
From: fear7trembling - I hope you're watching when it #25
Date: 01/28/26 @ 2:15 AM
Maybe I just didn’t like remick
I don't get the fascination with him, like wanting backstory and all that. Motherfucker had Roman gold, how much time do you think you have.
I guess he has a reason for existing as he does but that doesn't make him anything to like.
From: fear7trembling - I hope you're watching when it #26
Date: 01/28/26 @ 2:20 AM
The fight scene still sucked tho
I don't think it was supposed to be a good fight scene.
After the musical long take, it was essentially, "Well, we got to do it once, and now we have to die."
Like Slim saying "Yeah you pay twenty bucks tonight, but what about next night?"
But for three hours it was the best time.
From: bfte #27
Date: 01/28/26 @ 2:21 AM
i didn't like his long vampire fingers.

vampires should not have long fingers, it's gross and weird
they should have normal fingers.
From: bepto #28
Date: 01/28/26 @ 2:31 AM
Michael A. Jordan and Michael B. Jordan
From: fear7trembling - I hope you're watching when it #29
Date: 01/28/26 @ 2:33 AM
vampires should not have long fingers, it's gross and weird
they should have normal fingers
You're a little late on that, you're going to have take it back about a hundred years..
From: Rob #30
Date: 01/28/26 @ 2:33 AM
hubert cumberdale
From: slimwhitem #31
Date: 01/28/26 @ 2:55 AM
does that twenty bucks get me 24 hrs on there starting now until tomorrow at this time on there or is it midnight to midnight? just trying to force multiply every dollar i can these days, if that makes sense
From: fear7trembling - I hope you're watching when it #32
Date: 01/28/26 @ 2:57 AM
What in the fuck is you talking about.
From: haze - up the back stairs #33
Date: 01/28/26 @ 3:02 AM
"Oh, he busy, huh?" cracks me up every time.
From: Space Cat - please delete this account #34
Date: 01/28/26 @ 3:26 AM
My daughter and I just watched Hereditary and I thought the blurred lines between mental illness and demonic phenomena were brilliant, all the way to the end when you find out what's real.
I'll put it up there among my favorite horror movies along with The Witch and idk what else. I probably have some other favorite horror movies. Oh, X was unexpectedly great. I'm glad I saw Pearl first.
From: fear7trembling - I hope you're watching when it #35
Date: 01/28/26 @ 3:36 AM
Yeah, it's a masterclass in "Well you're not great people and maybe your brains are busted oh shit now there's a demon."
Also we regularly do Toni Collette with our dogs saying "Sitting there with that face on your face" and "Do NOT swear at me, I am your MOTHER" and they're like that's from the movie they have to give us treats to make us feel better.
From: haze - up the back stairs #36
Date: 01/28/26 @ 3:38 AM
I still haven't seen The Witch. Hereditary feels like a timeless, classic horror to me.
From: fear7trembling - I hope you're watching when it #37
Date: 01/28/26 @ 3:40 AM
Yeah, it's about a family who can't deal with a horrific tragedy but it was all their fault before and after and then whoops someone else did it on purpose.
From: fear7trembling - I hope you're watching when it #38
Date: 01/28/26 @ 3:43 AM
VVitch is kind of similar but it draws back to folk horror but more like hey sometimes your values and purity are more than you can handle and you just have to watch your household fall to pieces.
From: Space Cat - please delete this account #39
Date: 01/28/26 @ 3:44 AM
Yeah we stopped halfway through last night so my daughter could go to bed, then before we continued tonight, she started a conversation about whose fault the accident was, and it was a good talk, then welp.
From: fear7trembling - I hope you're watching when it #40
Date: 01/28/26 @ 3:53 AM
M is so smart, I love that.
And I think it's part of why horror gets the shoulder,
Because it's not necessarily about technique ore legacy,
But wrestles with questions that are like "That's not great, but is it in me? Is it here?"
Vampires are the plague, Can someone keep me enslaved beyond death, Am I possessed or did something happen to me, Is grief haunting my doors, What will people be like when society collapses, Can I be a good person or did someone already ruin it for me?
And people who most want to celebrate each other and not grapple with those things.

Please Login Or Create An Account To Join The Conversation